Review: Perhaps I am getting older, but this book did not appeal to me. The trope (child’s journey to save a sick parent) is a bit overdone. But I was prepared to overlook that (as any trope can work if handled well) particularly given the idea of the Savvy. The Savvy part of the story was the only good part of the story. Seeing Mibs struggle to accept hers, to “scumble” her Savvy, and to come to terms with the things in life that we can’t change. But the idea of the bus trip boring, the plot is drawn out, and the adults are feel like caricatures of real people and lack the depth of real people.
Sadly, this is the first Newbery that I didn’t enjoy. Not
that I think it’s bad or immoral, just not a good. However, I can see why
people would enjoy it and I would not dissuade anyone from reading it.
Bookmarks: 3.5 of 4
Awards: Newbery Honor (2009)
ISBN: 978-0-8037-3306-0
Year Published: 2008
Date Finished: 3-11-2018
Pages: 342
No comments:
Post a Comment